Legal Q&A
“If prisoners break the law in prison, does it get taken to the police and the courts?”
Ethan Cassidy
Donate Here
•
Legal Corner
Answer by Volunteer Barristers for About Time
Yes. If it is alleged that you have committed an offence in custody, you may be charged by police and the matter could go through the courts like any other offence.
If you are accused of committing an offence while you are in prison, it may be dealt with through an internal disciplinary process in the prison or it may go through the courts like an alleged offence in the community would.
This will likely depend on the seriousness of the alleged offence.
If this happens, it is important for you to get legal advice.
If you are charged with breaking a rule in prison, this can result in disciplinary action, in addition to potential criminal charges.
You have the right to a fair disciplinary hearing. In this hearing, a hearing officer will tell you about the procedure in the hearing, read the charge out to you and give you an opportunity to plead guilty or not guilty.
How the rest of the hearing will play out depends on whether you plead guilty or not guilty.
If you plead guilty, you will then be able to make a plea about what penalty you should receive, something that is called “submissions”. In submissions, you can talk about why the offence happened, what was happening to you at the time it happened and whether it’s the first time you have been in trouble for something like this.
If you plead not guilty, the hearing officer will likely then hear from witnesses, look at relevant information and listen to arguments on both sides. They will then make a decision about whether the prison offence occurred or not.
If you attend this hearing, you will have a chance to respond and present your own evidence.
Date Published
September 3, 2025
By About Time
By About Time
Through these articles, we provide information on relevant areas of law. This first article provides basic information to make it easier for family and friends to support you. There are differences in the ways the systems operate depending on where you’re located (VIC, NSW, ACT or TAS), so we hope this is useful and relevant to where you are.
ISSUE NO. 1
•
7 MIN READ
By Daniel Vansetten
By Daniel Vansetten
One of the most important aspects of self-advocacy in prison is to understand the rights of prisoners and the limitations of power of prison authorities.
ISSUE NO. 19
•
2 MIN READ
By Human Rights Law Centre and Prisoners’ Legal Service
By Human Rights Law Centre and Prisoners’ Legal Service
With people in prisons across the country being subjected to an “epidemic of prison lockdowns”, it is important to note that bare minimum safeguards exist in law, in most jurisdictions, that purport to guarantee at least some time ‘in the open air’ each day for people behind bars.
ISSUE NO. 22
•
5 MIN READ
By Human Rights Law Centre lawyer Monique Hurley, with assistance from Connor Shaw
By Human Rights Law Centre lawyer Monique Hurley, with assistance from Connor Shaw
In recent years, regressive reform of parole laws in many places has made it increasingly difficult for people in prison to access parole.
ISSUE NO. 23
•
4 MIN READ
By Prisoners’ Legal Service QLD
If you have been the victim of a crime, you may be able to apply for financial assistance through a government-run victim compensation scheme.
ISSUE NO. 27
•
3 MIN READ
By Anthony Burke
The law, like other professions, has its own language. It helps keep all the lawyers huddled around some special stuff and keep the rest of us outside.
ISSUE NO. 26
•
4 MIN READ
Prisoners’ Legal Service QLD
On 1 April 2026, the Australian Parliament passed new laws which will change the way Commonwealth parole works.
ISSUE NO. 25
•
3 MIN READ
By About Time
People in prison can apply to transfer from a prison in one state or territory to another, generally for welfare reasons to be closer to family, community supports, or rehabilitation opportunities.
ISSUE NO. 24
•
4 MIN READ