ONLINE NEWS
November 18, 2026
Donate Here
•

News and Investigations

Victorian Election Focuses on Locking Children Up Despite Falling Crime Rates

Denham Sadler is the Chief Reporter and Assistant Editor at About Time.

‍

Willy Pleasance

With less than two weeks to go until Victorians head to the polls, both major parties have announced plans to send more children to prison, despite the latest crime stats showing that youth crime is on the decline.

‍

Premier Ben Carroll recently announced a scheme to send children found guilty of low-level crimes such as vandalism and property damage to a youth prison for up to a year.

‍

Over the weekend, Opposition Leader Jess Wilson said that if elected, the Coalition would use the decommissioned Dhurringile Prison as a “bootcamp” for children, who would be made  to do daily tasks like farm work, cleaning and cooking.

‍

The major parties unveiled the dual youth crime policies soon after it was revealed that crime was on the decline in Victoria.

‍

The latest release from the Crime Statistics Agency Victoria, covering the 2025-26 financial year, reveals that the offence count in Victoria has dropped by more than 2 per cent in the last year, and the number of recorded offences was down by nearly 4 per cent.

‍

Youth offending dropped by more than 8 per cent in the last year.

‍

Overall, robbery rates have dropped by 22 per cent in the last year, burglary and break and enters have been down nearly 20 per cent, and theft is down 4 per cent.

‍

The Labor government has pledged to launch Mandatory Therapeutic Orders if it wins the upcoming election. These would allow for children convicted of low- and mid-level offences to be placed in youth detention for up to 12 months and receive mandatory health, drug and alcohol treatment and intensive education.

‍

Children would be detained  at the newly reopened Malmsbury Youth Detention Centre, with 30 beds  initially to be made available.

‍

The policy  will cost more than $141 million over the next five years.

‍

Carroll said that the plan to imprison more children for lower level crimes was “tough love”.

‍

“Right now, too many get a slap on the wrist,” he said.

‍

“Others aren’t completing their rehabilitation out in the community. It’s not a choice – it’s an order. Young people spiralling towards a life of crime shouldn’t get to walk away from the help they clearly need.”

‍

The announcement has sparked backlash from advocacy organisations and lawyers who regularly work with the children who will be impacted.

‍

“Taking kids away from their families, their school, their support networks and putting them into a ‘facility’ to try and force rehabilitation completely undermines the very purpose of that rehabilitation,” Stary Norton Halphen & Galbally partner Nick Jane said on LinkedIn.

‍

“Implementing policies like this will serve to isolate and criminalise an entire generation of children, which the science clearly and unequivocally says will lead to ongoing criminal behaviour into their adult years.”

‍

The positioning of the policy as “tough love” is “beyond decency”, Federation of Community Legal Centres Director of Policy and Advocacy Daniel Scoullar said.

‍

“It would be hard to invent a more cynical, cruel and counter-productive policy if you tried,” Scoullar said.

‍

“Locking up kids in this way would increase crime through more broken lives, at huge cost to the public and harm to kids and their families.”

‍

Under the Coalition’s plan, courts would have the power to send children aged 14 to 17 to a “bootcamp” program as an alternative to a community corrections order or custodial sentence.

‍

The children would be held at the Dhurringile prison, which was previously an adult prison, and made to complete  tasks including cleaning and maintenance.

‍

Child and adolescent psychologist Michael Carr-Gregg, an Officer of the Order of Australia, said that evidence on the effectiveness of bootcamps like these around the world was “not encouraging”.

‍

He said that a number of international reviews, including a meta-analysis of 32 studies, found no overall impact on the rates of reoffending among participants.

‍

“In more than 40 years as an adolescent psychologist, I have rarely met a young offender who didn’t have a story of trauma, family violence, school exclusion or an undiagnosed learning or neuro-developmental difficulty,” Carr-Gregg said on LinkedIn.

‍

“Tough and smart are not opposite. But if we want fewer victims, we have to fund what reduces reoffending, not what sounds good in a campaign ad.”

‍

The Queensland government conducted a trial of similar youth boot camps from 2013 to 2015 in the far north of the state.

‍

A  review of the program found that the rates of recidivism for participants were no different  than for those who had been in youth detention, with  the camps being far more expensive.

‍

The Queensland Attorney General at the time said that boot camps do not break the cycle of reoffending, while the report found their establishment had been in response to “public perceptions of increasing levels of youth crime”.

By Denham Sadler

The Queensland and Northern Territory governments have blocked the United Nations expert on the rights of Indigenous people from visiting youth prisons and meeting with officials.

‍

ONLINE NEWS
•
2 MIN READ
By Denham Sadler

In several Australian jurisdictions, police watch houses have become quasi-prison cells, as punitive crackdowns on bail and other “tough on crime” measures have filled jails across the country.

ONLINE NEWS
•
6 MIN READ
By Denham Sadler

Queensland prison authorities will no longer be required to consider and act in a way that is compatible with human rights when making decisions that affect people in prison, under legislation the state government has introduced to Parliament.

ONLINE NEWS
•
2 MIN READ
By About Time

Including a report released into youth education in Tasmania, a review into transfer of children to adult prisons in VIC and more.

ISSUE NO. 28
•
4 MIN READ

Welcome to About Time

About Time is the national newspaper for Australian prisons and detention facilities

Your browser window currently does not have enough height, or is zoomed in too far to view our website content correctly. Once the window reaches the minimum required height or zoom percentage, the content will display automatically.

Alternatively, you can learn more via the links below.

Donations via GiveNow

Email

Instagram

LinkedIn

Get All the Latest News From About Time in Your Inbox

Be the first to read each edition online and receive two newsletters each month filled with news stories, experiences, creativity and the voices of people in prison around the country.

X

X

You've successfully registered!
Something went wrong when we tried to register your details. Please try again.