Prison work differs across the country. According to one 2023 report, 48.8% of incarcerated people worked in prison operations (i.e. kitchens, laundry, gardening) and 29.7% in commercial industries (involved in making products or services designed to be sold to those outside the prison). Only 0.6% had work release. Incarcerated individuals who were ineligible for work included those with ill-health, those in full-time education and people on remand who chose not to work. The report also said there were more people in prison than there were available jobs. (Australian Productivity Commission)
There are different views about the aim of prison labour. Some say it’s a way for incarcerated people to give back to the community (either through the work itself or to pay victims’ compensation) or as a way for them to pay for prison services and goods (such as phone calls). Others think it helps to keep people busy or compliant with prison rules, instils discipline, or even acts as a deterrent from further offending, especially where the work is hard or boring.
Today, Australian governments say that the primary objective of prison labour is rehabilitation: assisting incarcerated people to get work after they are released from prison. But that is not the only reason for prison labour. One of the few Australian reviews into prison labour concluded that governments having competing and changing priorities for prison labour (e.g. rehabilitation versus recouping state costs of prisons) reduces the effectiveness of industries in prison.
There are international laws designed to protect workers against exploitation. One example, the Forced Labour Convention, is an international treaty against compulsory labour. Incarcerated people have some protections against forced labour under this Convention, but fewer protections than people in the community. Under the Forced Labour Convention, private companies, whether they are running an entire prison or just some of the work programs for incarcerated people, need the consent of the incarcerated people to work in their programs. The Convention also, however, allows governments to maintain work programs that require incarcerated people who are convicted to work.
There are also some labour protections in the Nelson Mandela Rules. The Nelson Mandela Rules are a set of guidelines adopted by the United Nations in 2015 which detail minimum standards for the safe, secure and dignified treatment of incarcerated people.
Some relevant Nelson Mandela Rules:
The Nelson Mandela Rules also detail some minimum standards for incarcerated workers similar to workers in the community, such as occupational health and safety protections and the regulation of working hours (Rule 101 and 102). On the other hand, Rule 103 of the Nelson Mandela Rules does not require that incarcerated people be paid the same minimum wage that people doing the same sort of work in the community earn.
Prison work differs across the country. According to one 2023 report, 48.8% of incarcerated people worked in prison operations (i.e. kitchens, laundry, gardening) and 29.7% in commercial industries (involved in making products or services designed to be sold to those outside the prison). Only 0.6% had work release. Incarcerated individuals who were ineligible for work included those with ill-health, those in full-time education and people on remand who chose not to work. The report also said there were more people in prison than there were available jobs. (Australian Productivity Commission)
There are different views about the aim of prison labour. Some say it’s a way for incarcerated people to give back to the community (either through the work itself or to pay victims’ compensation) or as a way for them to pay for prison services and goods (such as phone calls). Others think it helps to keep people busy or compliant with prison rules, instils discipline, or even acts as a deterrent from further offending, especially where the work is hard or boring.
Today, Australian governments say that the primary objective of prison labour is rehabilitation: assisting incarcerated people to get work after they are released from prison. But that is not the only reason for prison labour. One of the few Australian reviews into prison labour concluded that governments having competing and changing priorities for prison labour (e.g. rehabilitation versus recouping state costs of prisons) reduces the effectiveness of industries in prison.
There are international laws designed to protect workers against exploitation. One example, the Forced Labour Convention, is an international treaty against compulsory labour. Incarcerated people have some protections against forced labour under this Convention, but fewer protections than people in the community. Under the Forced Labour Convention, private companies, whether they are running an entire prison or just some of the work programs for incarcerated people, need the consent of the incarcerated people to work in their programs. The Convention also, however, allows governments to maintain work programs that require incarcerated people who are convicted to work.
There are also some labour protections in the Nelson Mandela Rules. The Nelson Mandela Rules are a set of guidelines adopted by the United Nations in 2015 which detail minimum standards for the safe, secure and dignified treatment of incarcerated people.
Some relevant Nelson Mandela Rules:
The Nelson Mandela Rules also detail some minimum standards for incarcerated workers similar to workers in the community, such as occupational health and safety protections and the regulation of working hours (Rule 101 and 102). On the other hand, Rule 103 of the Nelson Mandela Rules does not require that incarcerated people be paid the same minimum wage that people doing the same sort of work in the community earn.
It is important to keep in mind that for international laws or guidelines to be enforceable here in Australia, the protections need to be included in Australian law. Some Australian states and territories have included some of these protections in their Human Rights Acts (e.g. ACT, Queensland and Victoria), but not necessarily in their labour laws. Moreover, because Australian governments are guided by international law, the gaps in international labour protections for incarcerated people are unfortunately reflected in our Australian laws.
“Both internationally and in Australia, more work needs to be done to strengthen the rights of incarcerated workers.”
Last year, the United Nations’ independent expert on modern forms of slavery investigated work conditions for incarcerated and formerly incarcerated people and made some recommendations for change. Here are some of the expert’s recommendations:
The Australian Government has committed to uphold the United Nations’ human rights framework and should genuinely consider implementing these expert recommendations to better ensure that incarcerated workers are protected from exploitative labour practices and their human rights are protected.
There also needs to be greater transparency about prison labour in Australia, including in relation to how much incarcerated people are paid in prisons across the country and whether the work people do while in prison leads to employment upon release. Crucially, we need to understand better what is and what is not working from the perspective of those most impacted by current labour laws, policies and practices – incarcerated and formerly incarcerated workers.
It is important to keep in mind that for international laws or guidelines to be enforceable here in Australia, the protections need to be included in Australian law. Some Australian states and territories have included some of these protections in their Human Rights Acts (e.g. ACT, Queensland and Victoria), but not necessarily in their labour laws. Moreover, because Australian governments are guided by international law, the gaps in international labour protections for incarcerated people are unfortunately reflected in our Australian laws.
“Both internationally and in Australia, more work needs to be done to strengthen the rights of incarcerated workers.”
Last year, the United Nations’ independent expert on modern forms of slavery investigated work conditions for incarcerated and formerly incarcerated people and made some recommendations for change. Here are some of the expert’s recommendations:
The Australian Government has committed to uphold the United Nations’ human rights framework and should genuinely consider implementing these expert recommendations to better ensure that incarcerated workers are protected from exploitative labour practices and their human rights are protected.
There also needs to be greater transparency about prison labour in Australia, including in relation to how much incarcerated people are paid in prisons across the country and whether the work people do while in prison leads to employment upon release. Crucially, we need to understand better what is and what is not working from the perspective of those most impacted by current labour laws, policies and practices – incarcerated and formerly incarcerated workers.
Including tough bail laws being introduced in Victoria, the South Australian Government ruling out raising the age of criminal responsibility, a new parole board president appointed in Queensland and more.
The Australian Federal election is coming up. This is about voting for the Prime Minister and other federal politicians. It will be held on 3 May 2025.
“We can’t get information about how a party or candidate’s policies must impact prisoners,” Kelly told About Time. ‘Prison officers also will not provide us with any information as it is seen as political.”
The Midsumma Pride March sees tens of thousands march down Fitzroy Street in St Kilda, with many more turning out to cheer them on.
Help us get About Time off the ground. All donations are tax deductible and will be vital in providing an essential resource for people in prison and their loved ones.
Help us get About Time off the ground. All donations are tax deductible and will be vital in providing an essential resource for people in prison and their loved ones.
Your browser window currently does not have enough height, or is zoomed in too far to view our website content correctly. Once the window reaches the minimum required height or zoom percentage, the content will display automatically.
Alternatively, you can learn more via the links below.
Leave a Comment
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Suspendisse varius enim in eros elementum tristique. Duis cursus, mi quis viverra ornare, eros dolor interdum nulla, ut commodo diam libero vitae erat. Aenean faucibus nibh et justo cursus id rutrum lorem imperdiet. Nunc ut sem vitae risus tristique posuere. uis cursus, mi quis viverra ornare, eros dolor interdum nulla, ut commodo diam libero vitae erat. Aenean faucibus nibh et justo cursus id rutrum lorem imperdiet. Nunc ut sem vitae risus tristique posuere.